Rye and mezcal split the base of this stirred sipper, with Sicilian amaro bringing cola-like bittersweet depth under a wisp of smoke.
Category: Popular
Glass: Old fashioned glass
ABV: 28%
Difficulty: Easy
Ingredients
Rye whiskey30 ml (1 oz)
Mezcal15 ml (0.5 oz)
Amaro15 ml (0.5 oz)
Simple syrup1 tsp
Angostura bitters2 dash
How to Make It
Add all ingredients to a mixing glass with ice.
Stir until well chilled.
Strain over a large ice cube in a rocks glass.
Express an orange peel over the drink and drop it in.
Garnish
Orange peel
What it tastes like
It has a bitter backbone, smoke dominates the nose and the spirit is right out front.
The technique
Stirring. All-spirit drinks are stirred — shaking whips air into them and ruins both the clarity and the texture. Thirty to forty seconds in a mixing glass, the spoon tracing the wall. You are after the same ~20% dilution, just slower and under control.
Glass and ice
A heavy-bottomed, wide old fashioned glass. Wide enough for one large cube, which is the point: a big cube has less surface area, so the drink gets cold without getting watery.
Ingredient notes and substitutes
Rye whiskey
Rye whiskey. Where bourbon is sweet, rye brings black pepper and a mint-like sharpness; in drinks with sweet vermouth, like a Manhattan, that sharpness is what holds the balance.
Mezcal
The Mexican spirit whose smoke comes from roasting the agave in a stone pit. It can stand in for tequila, but the smoke walks over everything else; starting half and half is the balanced move.
Amaro
The umbrella name for Italian bitter liqueurs, and no two are alike. Averna is sweet and caramelly, Fernet sharp and minty, Montenegro floral — which is why a recipe naming a brand means it.
Simple syrup
One part sugar to one part water, stirred until it dissolves — no need to boil it. Keeps a month in the fridge. No syrup? Use the same amount of honey, loosened with a little water.
Angostura bitters
The salt of the cocktail world. Measured in dashes, not millilitres: a few of them cut the sweetness and add spice. One bottle lasts years.
The Story
A home-bar recipe shared in the online cocktail community, in the style of the split-base amaro Old Fashioneds that modern American bars made popular.
Frequently asked questions
How is a Going Out West mixed?
It is stirred and served in an old fashioned glass.
How strong is a Going Out West?
Roughly 28% ABV as served — a spirit-strength drink — sipped slowly, and it wants a glass of water beside it.
Can a Going Out West be made without alcohol?
Simply leaving the spirit out does not work — the body and the bitterness go with it. The 86 alcohol-free recipes in the catalogue are built to hit that balance from the start.
Is a Going Out West hard to make?
Easy. No bar kit required — a measure, ice and a jar will do.
🍸
759 recipes in your pocket
Cocktails and mocktails from 55 countries — ingredients, steps and the story behind each drink. Works offline too.