Read the guide

DOI or ISBN? Match the identifier to the source you used

Distinguish a publication identifier from a search result and keep article versions, book editions and formats visible.

An identifier narrows a search, but you still need to know what it identifies. A DOI may identify an article, dataset or another registered object. An ISBN identifies a particular book product or edition and format within its system.

Choose the identifier from the item you actually consulted. Copying one from a nearby search result can attach the right-looking reference to the wrong work.

For an article, compare the complete record

When a DOI is printed with an article, follow it and compare the title, author list and publication details. If you have a preprint, check whether a separate published version exists and which one you are quoting.

Do not change a preprint reference into the journal version while keeping page numbers or wording taken from the earlier file. The version matters when someone tries to reproduce your reading.

For a book, check the physical or electronic product

Use the ISBN and edition statement from the version in front of you. A paperback, hardback and ebook can have distinct identifiers. A title alone may lead to a different publication year or a revised edition.

For a chapter written by separate authors, record the chapter and the containing book as the required style specifies. The book's ISBN helps locate the container; it does not replace the chapter title, author or page range.

Keep a short comparison record

Save five fields while checking: source type, identifier, title, version or edition, and the location of the passage you used. If a lookup disagrees, inspect the disagreement before editing the reference.

Citelle accepts DOI, ISBN, links and titles, and lets you edit fields manually. A lookup is a starting record rather than a command to overwrite the publication's evidence. On this website, the ISBN checker only validates arithmetic and the manual citation builder only formats your entries.

  • Compare records with the item itself.
  • Keep page or section notes separate from the identifier.
  • Mark uncertainty rather than supplying guessed metadata.

Questions, answered

Can a DOI prove that a claim is true?

No. It helps identify an object. Evaluating a claim requires reading and assessing the source itself.

Can I use a book ISBN as an article identifier?

Use identifiers for the objects they identify. An ISBN may identify a book containing a chapter, while an article or chapter may have its own DOI.

Sources & method

Reviewed:

Keep going in Citelle

Look up DOI, ISBN, links or titles and scan book ISBN barcodes · Check reference lists against records, with differences visible for close matches · Bibliographies stay on iPhone; Pro adds all eight styles, full checks and RTF/BibTeX/RIS export

Get the iPhone app

Keep exploring