Read the guide

Check an AI-generated reference without assuming the answer

Verify the publication, compare the metadata and read the source before deciding whether a reference supports an AI-generated claim.

A convincing reference can contain a real author, a plausible title and a DOI belonging to a different article. Check the individual fields against the publication rather than judging the reference by how professionally it is written.

Keep three questions separate: does a record exist, does it match the reference, and does the source support the claim? A positive answer to one does not answer the others.

Look for a record using more than one clue

Start with an exact DOI if present, then compare the resolved title and authors. If the identifier is missing or mismatched, search the title and a distinctive author surname in an appropriate catalogue or scholarly index.

Change the query deliberately rather than repeatedly pasting the same long reference. Remove broken punctuation or use a short distinctive title phrase. Keep a note of which search produced a possible match.

Compare fields before accepting a close result

Check title, author order, year, publication venue, volume, pages or article number, and identifier. A near-identical title can belong to another edition, a preprint, a correction or a separate work.

Use a simple review record with three states: matched, needs review, and not located. 'Not located' describes your search outcome; it is not proof of fabrication. Local journals, older books and grey literature may not appear in the services you checked.

Read the source for the actual claim

Open the original publication and inspect the relevant passage, not only a search snippet or abstract. Record a page, section or figure and explain how it relates to your sentence. A real publication can be cited for a conclusion it never made.

Citelle checks reference lists against record services and shows differences for close matches. Use that to organise the first stages, then complete the reading yourself. This web guide does not send text to an AI service or perform live reference lookups.

  • Keep the original generated reference for comparison.
  • Do not silently replace it with a different paper.
  • Ask a librarian or subject specialist when the record remains uncertain.

Questions, answered

Is a resolving DOI enough?

No. Compare the returned work with the reference, then read it to establish whether it supports your claim.

Does 'not found' mean fake?

No. It can reflect incomplete metadata, search mismatch or limited database coverage. Record the uncertainty and investigate further.

Sources & method

Reviewed:

Keep going in Citelle

Look up DOI, ISBN, links or titles and scan book ISBN barcodes · Check reference lists against records, with differences visible for close matches · Bibliographies stay on iPhone; Pro adds all eight styles, full checks and RTF/BibTeX/RIS export

Get the iPhone app

Keep exploring